Sunday Discussion: Alexandria’s Appomattox Statue (Open Thread)

For this week’s Sunday Discussion, a debate that began with the Confederate flag, then the Confederate flag on Virginia license plates now focuses on some of Virginia’s most iconic sights – the Confederate statues (see this link, this link, and this link for examples).

In Alexandria, Virginia, City Councilman Justin Wilson called the City’s Appomattox statue ‘problematic’ this week. The statue, erected in 1889 to honor Alexandrians who died fighting for the Confederate army, is protected by state law and only the Virginia General Assembly can order its removal.

On the statue is a plaque with this inscription:

“THE CONFEDERATE STATUE

The unarmed Confederate soldier standing in the intersection of Washington and Prince Streets marks the location where units from Alexandria left to join the Confederate Army on May 24, 1861. The soldier is facing the battlefields to the South where his comrades fell during the War Between the States. The names of those Alexandrians who died in service for the Confederacy are inscribed on the base of the statue. The title of the sculpture is “Appomattox” by M. Casper Buberl.

The statue was erected in 1889 by the Robert E. Lee Camp United Confederate Veterans.”

So, I’d like to know what you think. Should it be removed? Why or why not?

As always, feel free to sound off about this topic, or any other topic you want to discuss in the comments below.

Memorial to the Confederate Dead of Alexandria

(Photo by Cliff, on Flickr)

33 Comment

  • It’s our history, and absolutely should NOT be removed. This is getting really ridiculous!
    You can’t rewrite history, and isn’t the importance of history that which we learn from it? Taking down monuments/memorials will do nothing but store the flames on the issue, and is a complete insult to the the famous of those who died and for which the monuments and memorials were erected.

  • The charm of Old Town Alexandria is that it is a Historic City. There is History and a story behind every structure including statues such as this one of the unarmed confederate soldier. The statue is a symbol of all those Alexandrians who died fighting in the Confederate army and its location has significance of where the army united.
    The thought of removing it is Preposterous! Why???

  • It should not be removed. It is a part of US history, Alexandria, and Virginia. If it is removed, what’s next-tear down Mount Vernon since
    Washington owned slaves???? This is all getting out of hand. A piece of cloth and monuments did not cause a lunatic to murder innocent people!!

  • The removal of this or any other confederate statue is crazy. It’s part of our history. Yes, the confederate flag is part of our history too. Put the flags in museums. I agree they should not be flown over public buildings; but tearing down statues is just over the top.

  • The Civil War was real. It is a part of history. Leave the statue.

  • I wrote this post a few years ago.
    My views remain the same. This should stay put but can be put in context. http://dclawyeronthecivilwar.blogspot.com/2010/06/symbols-of-lost-cause-in-alexandria.html?m=1

  • QKEEP THIS MEMORIAL STATUE DO NOT LET THE CRAZY LIBERALS TRY To rewrite history, I am an 81+ year old woman born in Charlottesville and raised in Alexandria We ere taught to respect this statue to honor the men who perished in the Civil war. I am about to check out and regret leaving the mess this country is in to our children Obama & The Supreme court are destroying our country 1 statue 1 flag at a time.Our children are not being tauhistoryPLEASE KEEP THE STATUE

  • I was born in Arlington and grew up in Alexandria. The statue is part of our local, southern and national heritage. Removing it is a vicious political statement from the left. How ironic when the Democrats were the leaders in slavery, segregation and to this day thriving on race baiting. The statue is a part of American history. It needs to stay. It does no harm to anyone. The statue is not a symbol for racism. It serves as a reminder of what we came from, what we sacrificed, how our nation grew and evolved. Removing the statue would be an insult to people who call Alexandria home.

    • I live in Alexandria and I couldn’t care less about the statue. I just want to know when the Potomac Yard Metro station will be built.

  • When will this madness stop? Who is that statue hurting. Is every Conferate memorial going down because of politucs and knee jerk reactions. The racial sutuation is being exacerbated by politics and fear of violent protests by groups who are the real haters and racists. What is happening to our country?

  • First of all, it is not a Confederate “statue”; it is a monument, one which remembers those from the City of Alexandria who died in the Civil War. That point must not be forgotten, or else it will not be possible to have a complete and meaningful discussion about the “Appomattox” monument. Having said this, let’s look at this latest “controversy”.

    City Councilman Justin Wilson ignorantly said that “the nature of that memorial and the glorification of that cause I think is problematic” and that he doesn’t feel that “a statue honoring that cause” is appropriate. Has Justin Wilson even bothered to read and, even more, to understand the inscription “in context,” as he likes to say? Most likely not. More than likely, he simply views that monument — monument, Justin, not “statue” — as some unbearable :glorification” of slavery. How willfully ignorant can the man be? Plenty, it would seem.

    When the Civil War began (1861), our nation was only 72 years old, the U.S. Constitution having been ratified in 1789. The states that ratified the Constitution in no way viewed themselves as vassal territories of the centralized federal government but rather as sovereign states except on matters (such as commerce) that they had ceded certain enumerated powers to the federal government.

    The Commonwealth of Virginia was NOT one of the seven states that had seceded from the Union, on 04 February 1861 (prior to Abraham Lincoln’s inauguration). Furthermore, a meeting of representatives from Virginia convened on 13 February 1861 to decide the secession question and, on 04 April, defeated the motion to secede. However, when President Lincoln issued a call to all states in the Union for troops to reply to the Confederate capture of Fort Sumter, the Virginia delegates voted on 17 April to secede. The next day, federal troops attacked the City of Alexandria without any hostile provocation from Virginia having occurred.

    Given the view of state sovereignty versus federal authority at the time, it is quite understandable that the citizens of Virginia (and especially the residents of Alexandria) would view the federal attack as an intolerable incursion upon Commonwealth sovereignty. Hence, the inscription on the north side of the monument’s base reads: “They died in the consciousness of duty faithfully performed.” That is all it says. It does not call for the return of slavery, nor does it lament the abolition of that “peculiar institution.” It merely remembers those men from the City of Alexandria who died in a conflict while performing the duty — the defense of Virginia’s sovereignty — that they, in good faith and conscience, saw fit to do.

    The monument does not “glorify” slavery, as opportunistic politicians like Justin Wilson like to claim. It simply remembers men from the City of Alexandria who died in the Civil War defending their home city and home commonwealth. If Justin Wilson wants to view things “in context,” as he says in his WAMU interview, he should take time to understand the context of the monument. Of course, he has no interest in that, because doing so would undermine his racialist agenda. But, if he feels that others are uncomfortable with the monument — it’s always for “others”, isn’t it, Justin? — perhaps he should help such “others” understand the true meaning of the monument by educating them about this wonderful piece of his city’s history, instead of engaging in divisive measures for political gain.

    Bear in mind that only about 6% of the people in the South owned any slaves. The other 94 % were either too poor or felt slavery was in conflict with their faith. So, it is highly unlikely that most of the soldiers who fought for the Confederacy were trying to maintain something (i.e., slavery) in which they had no vested interest. Their main concern was more likely the freedom of their respective states, and the defense thereof, from an intrusive federal government.

    So, with regard the question, “Should the monument be removed or relocated?”, the answer is an emphatic and unqualified “No !” Instead, the city should further protect the monument, perhaps with some of the median around it restored and expanded (as old photographs show), and highlight its history and true meaning, namely the love and devotion that caused old soldiers to raise such a monument in the memory of their fallen comrades-in-arms.

    • Scott… Intelligent, informative, and factually correct response! Good Job. By, the way, I’m from south Louisiana. There were a lot of confederate soldiers with the last name “Wilson”. Maybe Justin should change his name.

    • “So, it is highly unlikely that most of the soldiers who fought for the Confederacy were trying to maintain something (i.e., slavery) in which they had no vested interest.”

      Myth. Speeches by pro secesh speakers at the time emphasized the benefits of slavery to poor whites, in particular that it would save them from equal social status with blacks. Also do not forget that the South was still America, where many poor expected to become rich – just as today, if not more so. And many non slave owning whites benefited economically from slavery – as overseers, providers of goods and services to planters, etc.

    • “First of all, it is not a Confederate “statue”; it is a monument, one which remembers those from the City of Alexandria who died in the Civil War.”

      Incorrect -it specifically says the Confederate dead. Any Alexandrians, black or white, whoi died fighting for the Union are excluded.

    • The minute Virginia (and the other states) joined the cause, they allowed the SC Declaration of Secession to speak for them. I highly recommend everyone read it themselves, but a few of my favorite passages:

      “A geographical line has been drawn across the Union, and all the States north of that line have united in the election of a man to the high office of President of the United States, whose opinions and purposes are hostile to slavery. He is to be entrusted with the administration of the common Government, because he has declared that that “Government cannot endure permanently half slave, half free,” and that the public mind must rest in the belief that slavery is in the course of ultimate extinction. […] This sectional combination for the submersion of the Constitution, has been aided in some of the States by elevating to citizenship, persons who, by the supreme law of the land, are incapable of becoming citizens…”

      But since we like to elevate Virginia to martyrdom status and suggest they were simply upholding the dignity of the state… From Richmond’s Southern Punch in 1864: “Our doctrine is this: WE ARE FIGHTING FOR INDEPENDENCE THAT OUR GREAT AND NECESSARY DOMESTIC INSTITUTION OF SLAVERY SHALL BE PRESERVED, and for the preservation of other institutions of which slavery is the groundwork.”

  • Mr. Wilson… You are “problematic” and should never be re-elected.

  • This seems very different from the Confederate Battle Flag, whose use was revived in the 1950s as a symbol of defiance against segregation. I would however like to hear how african american citizens of our City feel before I take a definite position on this.

    How those of you who use this to express vitriol against liberals, or to call for preservation of EVERY such statue (Is it really not conceivable that some should be removed ? How about those to Nathan Bedford Forrest?) etc are not doing honor to the South.

  • Keep the Statue if you like, but in the green space between King and Washington erect a statue of a black soldier from the same era.

  • Even better than my first suggestion, I propose that we erect a Slave Statue at the waterfront, to honor all the slaves that were ripped from their families and sold into bondage during the Alexandria Slave Trade era.

  • The confederate monument on Washington street is as much a part of Alexandria as Market square or Gadsbys or the countless other buildings and landmarks that make up our great little city. It represents an important part of our and the nations history and needs to remain exactly where it is. It is shameful that Mr. Wilson has chosen this issue to display political cowardice rather than true leadership. Thank you for highlighting this story for us and I hope it is the only time we have to hear about it.

  • This statue has been part of my growing up. It should remain.. How many of these Alexandrians were slave owner? Probably very few. Were they fighting for the “rights” of a handful of slaveowners? probably not. All this BS about the Battle Flag and monuments is a loot of PC BS. those are/were symbols to commemorate brave men, no matter what “cause” they fought for, states rights, independence, even the right (as it was back then) to own another person. Remember, FIVE border states and territories had slavery and they were in the Oh So Holy NORTH, where the jobs, housing and other conditions in many cases were worse than the plantations. It’s over, people. Let the symbols stay. To wish history away and pretend it didn’t happen is foolish. Those were different times.
    So what about today? Slavery is still practiced in Africa, and has been for thousands of years. Nothing has changed except the “customer base.”

  • I see no Confederate flag. Why the uproar? This was part of history — if we go on nitpicking like this — then ALL the monuments honoring all the war dead from the Civil War would be affected.

  • I knew it was only a matter of time before the PC Police came to our town.
    The statue on Prince Street is what it is. A historical statue which was erected to commemorate Alexandria’s fallen sons. Nothing more. Nothing less.
    It’s a shame that some in our town, especially our elected town leaders, are now resorting to actions which may best be described as a form of a modern day book burning. Because make no mistake, this is what Mr. Wilson and those who follow him are attempting to do. They are taking a piece of history and attempting to destroy or remove that piece of history so that it no longer exists. It can no longer be seen and therefore in time it will fade from memory. The Soviet Union, Communist China and North Korea all engaged in the act of destroying certain parts of history from their countries past. Throughout history radical groups held massive book burnings with the intent of erasing from existence those items which some found offensive. More recently, the world was appalled when the Taliban began destroying historical statues and religious artifacts throughout the lands they conquered with the goal of eradicating everything they disliked. And now in Alexandria, Virginia, it appears we have yet another group of modern day “book burners,” if you will, whose intent is on erasing a part of a city’s history because some find a memorial to the fallen sons of that city offensive.
    I’m curious to see where the next mayor stands on this subject. Does she side with the city’s history? Or does she believe in book-burning?

  • Ms. Kebe, I believe your idea is a fine one. I

  • Ms. Kebe,
    Your suggestion is good.

  • I disagree with Ms. Kebe’s suggestion. The Confederate statue was placed there as a memorial by family and friends of the fallen. To just start erecting statues for no other reason than countering the memorials already in place, such as by erecting an object (the black soldier) makes little sense.

  • I don’t know why this piece was written as it was. Obviously those of you commenting didn’t bother to investigate what actually took place. There was no vote to remove the statue. There was a discussion about moving it to the Lyceum. So you hold off on your righteous indignation.

    • Vice Mayor Justin Wilson has to be stopped. He is ruining the very city that we love by taking unwarranted short sided stances on issues such as this. Removing or moving this statue is doing nothing to help repair race relations. It’s a monument to fallen confederate soldiers not a celebration of slavery. Why do we have to erase our history. Yes it was wrong but if we don’t remember things/learn from things in our history we tend to repeat them. I for one will not be voting for Wilson the next time he is up for reelection he is the leader of this city counsel of flaming liberals.