Severance

Serial Killer Convicted of Three Murders Spanning a Decade

On November 2, 2015, Charles Stanard Severance was convicted of three murders committed in the City of Alexandria over the span of a decade. The aggregate sentenced recommended by the jury was three life sentences, plus 48 years of incarceration and a fine of $400,000.

After the verdicts were returned, Commonwealth’s Attorney Bryan Porter addressed the press. His remarks are contained below in their entirety:

“The reign of the Alexandria Assassin is over. At long last, the defendant has been held accountable and exposed for what he really is – a clever, but cowardly, murderer.

A jury of twelve citizens, good and true, has held the defendant accountable by finding him guilty of the murders of Nancy Dunning, Ron Kirby and Ruthanne Lodato, and the malicious wounding of Janet Franco. Jury service is a difficult proposition in a case such as this, requiring the jurors to expend great deals of time, attention and commitment. I thank the jury for their thoughtful and deliberative service on this, the most grave of cases.

My first thoughts are with the victims of these senseless crimes. Nancy Dunning, Ronald Kirby and Ruthanne Lodato were wonderful people – three precious human souls who were gunned down in the sanctity of their own homes by a depraved human being.

My thoughts are also with the families and friends of Nancy, Ron and Ruthanne. Throughout the pendency of this case, the quiet dignity, resolve and resolution shown by these wonderful people, all victimized by these senseless acts, has served as a source of inspiration to the trial team.

Unfortunately, as prosecutors, we are only human beings. That means that we are incapable of truly righting the horrendous wrong done in this case. The trial team fervently hopes that our work on this case has brought a modicum of solace and relief to the friends and families of the victims.

An investigation as complex and lengthy as this one required an immense amount of work by an incredible number of people. I start by thanking Attorney General Mark Herring. Mark is an outstanding public servant. When the enormity of this case became apparent, I requested assistance from the Attorney General. He immediately and unequivocally told me that he would support me in any way he could.

The most important assistance the General provided was authorizing two Assistant Attorneys General from his Major Crimes and Emerging Threats Unit, Marc Birnbaum and James Entas. These two seasoned trial attorneys comprised half of the trial team, and this outcome would not have been reached without their important contributions. I would also like to personally thank Deputy Attorney General Linda Bryant for her assistance and advice during the pendency of this matter.

The law enforcement officers who worked on this case are the paradigm of what public servants should be. Before the defendant was identified and arrested, dozens of police detectives, sheriff’s deputies and federal agents toiled tirelessly to break the case and bring a sense of relief to the community. I would like to personally commend the following law enforcement agencies by name: the Alexandria Police Department, the Federal Bureau of Investigation, the Loudoun County Sheriff’s Office and the Wheeling, West Virginia Police Department. I would also like to thank the following officers, detectives and agents by name: Detective Sergeant Dave Cutting, Sergeant Sean Casey, Detective Will Oakley, Lieutenant Mike Kochis of the Alexandria Police Department, FBI Agent Erin Sheridan and members of the FBI’s Behavioral Analysis Unit, Detective Steven Schochet from the Loudoun County Sheriff’s Office and Corporal Doug Howell of the Wheeling Police Department. Of course, there are many more law enforcement officers who deserve credit for their work on this case, but time unfortunately prohibits me from naming them all. Suffice it to say that these officers and agents worked this case with nobility and grace, and their labors produced the correct result – the conviction of a violent murderer.

I specifically thank the following people without whom this conviction could not have been obtained: my office administrator, Donald Harrison-Wright, my Victim-Witness Coordinator, Judy Holl, one of my Victim-Witness advocates, Lisa Bowman, our law clerks, Christin Mitchell and Susan Brock, Loudoun County Commonwealth’s Attorney Jim Plowman and Ohio County, West Virginia Prosecuting Attorney Scott Smith.

I cannot finish these remarks without highlighting the immense contributions made to this case by Alexandria Senior Assistant Commonwealth’s Attorneys, David Lord. David is simply one of the best trial attorneys in the Commonwealth. He is an outstanding attorney and a better person. His indefatigable energy motivated the entire trial team, and to him goes the lion’s share of the credit for this outstanding outcome.

As I noted in my summation, violence does not win in the end – love wins. It has been my privilege to represent the Commonwealth and the City of Alexandria with regards to this matter.”

Formal sentencing of the defendant was set for January 22, 2016, in the Fairfax Circuit Court.

Real Time Analytics